Greenfingers

Rating:

Flower Power

Main Cast: Clive Owen, Helen Mirren

Director: Joel Hershman

This review was written way back in 2004 when I was a newbie movie reviewer. I used more words then, and fewer Oxford commas. I’m leaving it as it is, an ancient internet museum exhibit with extra adjectives.

British comedy is an interesting thing. Not Benny Hill type comedy, but what I can only describe as the British equivalent of the American romantic comedy. Not crossover movies, either (like Love, Actually or Notting Hill or I guess anything with Hugh Grant), intended to appeal to an American audience. I mean British comedy for a British audience. These are films with a core storyline that has little to do with romance – that being an important, but secondary, component to the film. Rather, the films have actual plots, ones that do not revolve around boy getting girl, losing girl, getting girl back, blah, blah, blah. Greenfingers is just such a movie.

Greenfingers stars Clive Owen as Colin Briggs. Colin has spent his entire adult life, fifteen years, in prison. When he is abruptly transferred from a maximum security facility to an “open prison” he suffers quite a bit of culture shock. The open prison is far more like a dormitory with job training than anything else. The inmates have tremendous freedom (for prisoners) as they make the transition from prison life to eventual parole. Colin wants no part of it, remaining surly and isolated with a dismissive attitude toward this place and those that live and work here. Only slowly is he brought into this rather odd little community by his roommate Fergus (David Kelly). He eventually accepts a work assignment as, of all things, a gardener.

Colin and the others assigned to creating this garden have no knowledge, no skills. They must acquire those, as well as making due with poor soil and worse equipment. The other inmates jeer at this “unmanly” project – to the indignation of some of the crew. Only Fergus is contentedly committed to making this a reality – he already has a love for plants and his quiet assurance stands in sharp contrast to the fumbling of the others. Fergus is the heart of this crew and this project.

The gardening inmates and their creation are eventually brought to the attention of one Georgina Woodhouse (Helen Mirren channeling Martha Stewart so well it must be seen to be believed), maven of English gardening. It is she who is responsible for turning a prison experiment into something far grander.

This all sounds terribly contrived, doesn’t it? The convicts being redeemed through the act of working with the earth, nurturing and growing. The spotlight inexplicably turned upon them. The inevitable setbacks and romances. It would indeed be terribly contrived were it not for one tiny detail. It’s true. The events depicted in Greenfingers (an English term equivalent to the American “green thumb”) by writer/director Joel Hershman actually happened. It isn’t a new story, underdogs and their triumphs have been film fodder for decades. Hundreds of such films exist, perhaps as a testament to our delight in seeing the little guy beat insurmountable odds. It’s a good formula. It’s an even better formula when it’s based on real people. The power of the underdog is that much greater when the underdog actually exists in the world somewhere. Greenfingers benefits from our love of the underdog and steps it up a notch by using real underdogs. I seem to have fallen in love with the term “underdog”.

The film itself moves at a leisurely pace, without chaotic highs or overly dramatically lows. This seems to be something British comedies frequently exhibit. The situation may be familiar, but it isn’t treated with the hyperactive style to which American audiences have unfortunately become familiar. There are some nice relationships that develop, but none is overplayed for laughter or tears. The filmmakers set the comedy and drama in front of us and let us decide whether to laugh or cry. This absence of blatant emotional manipulation is refreshing – the humor is subtle and the pathos handled gracefully.

The performances are solid but again, subdued. Clive Owen is not an outgoing protagonist. He plays Colin as introverted and quiet, not at all given to histrionics. The only real exception is Helen Mirren, who essentially plays the comic foil. Her blunt opinions and ebullient television coverage of flower shows are very funny, but not so over the top as to be incongruent with the rest of the film. In general, Greenfingers has a nice ensemble cast that plays off of one another subtly with flashes of genuine humor and drama.

Photographer John Daly deserves special mention as the shots of the gardens and flowers are really quite lovely. His visuals definitely help the viewer get into the gardening story, not necessarily an easy sell. Watching the plants grow and seeing the outcome of the prisoners efforts makes the accomplishment more impressive, and the viewer more appreciative.

Overall, Greenfingers is a fairly fun story of redemption through gardening. The fact that it’s based on a true story adds a layer of interest to the underdog saga. The performances are solid, the pace leisurely and the photography very pretty. This is not a film that will knock your socks off, but it’s a sweet story, well executed and refreshingly lacking in the overt rom/com stupidity in which American filmgoers have been involuntarily steeping for years. A nice change of pace for those looking for a romantic comedy that won’t make you want to hurl invectives at the screen, Greenfingers is definitely worth a watch.

Related posts

Get Netflix Dates emailed free to you every week

We email Movie Rewind's Netflix release dates weekly and never share or sell your address. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy